'Let the Girl Have Red:' Atlanta Woman Buys Kia Sportage. Then She's Told She Made a Mistake

"Everything is sooo ugly now."

Atlanta Woman Gets Kia Sportage

Photo by: Unsplash.com

Chad Swiatecki

By: Chad Swiatecki

Nov 2, 2025 at 8:00am ET

Add Motor1.com as a preferred source in Google

Comment

When an Atlanta woman took to TikTok to vent about her Kia Sportage’s problems, she didn’t expect the internet to turn her heartbreak into a referendum on car buying itself. Her critics said she should’ve cared more about reliability. Her supporters said, “Let the girl want red seats.” The argument reveals a great deal about what people truly value behind the wheel.

The viral clip from frustrated Sportage owner Ashley (@its.aferg) is part of a series of videos where she shares details of a series of malfunctions with the car, which often runs with its instrument panel illuminated, displaying warnings about problems that return despite repeated repair attempts at the dealership.

The experience has started to sour Ashley on what had been her top choice in a vehicle, and she turned to her viewing public for help.

“With my car acting up and them not being able to figure it out, and me possibly having to get a new car, it's really upsetting to me and my homegirls because I love this car,” she said in the clip that’s been viewed more than 140,000 times.

“I don't see anything on the market right now that's in my price range that I like. Everything is ugly,” she adds.

The Sportage has become a standout in its segment largely thanks to its bold styling and tech-rich interior. Following its all-new design for the 2023 model year, the 2024 Sportage features distinctive boomerang-shaped LED signatures, striking profile lines, and a cabin centered around twin digital screens. Buyers like Ashley say they’re drawn to its look, with the red seats, the high-tech dashboard, and the idea of a crossover that doesn't resemble “every other SUV.” But the very same features that attract enthusiasts also spark debate: When the aesthetic appeal is high, expectations for performance and longevity rise accordingly.

Kia Sportage: Popularity Meets Scrutiny

Globally, Kia reported that the Sportage ranked as its top-selling model in 2024, with approximately 587,717 units moved. In the US, Kia broke its own records in 2023 and 2024, with SUVs and utility vehicles comprising the majority of its growing volume. Yet that very success may amplify buyer expectations, and risk backlash when reliability doesn’t match the hype.

For buyers, the fundamental question becomes: beyond the look, will the car hold up? According to industry ratings, the Sportage performs reasonably well, but with caveats. J.D. Power lists the 2024 Sportage with a consumer-rating score of 83 out of 100 for reliability. RepairPal gives it a reliability rating of 4.0 out of 5 and estimates an average annual repair cost of $462, ranking it 6th out of 26 in compact SUVs. On the flip side, Consumer Reports notes that the redesigned Sportage “has an uncomfortable ride, clumsy handling, and a noisy, unrefined powertrain,” suggesting that there may be trade-offs.

While the Sportage is above average in some metrics, it isn’t immune to owner complaints, especially when problems start to accumulate. For someone in Ashley’s position with their first major car purchase and a strong emotional investment, the pain of reliability issues feels amplified. She picked the Sportage because it looked and felt right and had features like heated seats, red interior, and a touchscreen dash. Yet the messaging from her comments section shifted quickly: “You should’ve cared about reliability,” one commenter said. Others jumped in: “Let the girl want red seats.”

What emerges from the TikTok thread is a microcosm of the modern car-buying conundrum. On one side, buyers want a vehicle that reflects their identity and aesthetic preferences. On the other hand, the internet has become a collective reliability checker, with brands like Lexus, Mazda CX-5, and Nissan Murano regularly promoted for their durability as “safe” choices. Ashley’s line, “Why do I have to choose?” captures the frustration of wanting both.

Gallery: 2026 Kia Sportage

2026 Kia Sportage

2026 Kia Sportage Interior

Source: Kia

What’s Next For the Sportage Driver?

As she contemplates whether to replace the Sportage and whether to replace it with the same model or abandon the brand altogether, her predicament reflects a broader moment of reckoning for automakers: design may drive sales, but reliability keeps the customer.

For shoppers, the takeaway is this: Don’t let looks alone override your inspection of ongoing owner reports and real-world reliability. The Sportage delivers standout style and strong value, but it isn’t bulletproof. Matching your emotional needs (looks, features) with pragmatic expectations (durability, repair history) may reduce the chance of winding up in Ashley’s shoes; loving the car one day, only to be tired of it the next.

What do you think?

View

Comments

Ashley’s TikTok may start with red seats and dashboard love, but it ends with a more universal question: Can we still buy a car for how it looks, and trust it will still work a year or two down the road?

Motor1 reached out to Ashley via email and direct message. We’ll be sure to update this if she responds.

What Owners Are Saying

‘Not What They Come With:’ Mechanic Works On VW Golf. Then He Spots Suspicious Tires—and Calls Dealership

'No Way': Nashville Woman Goes to Valvoline for Oil Change and Coolant Flush. Then Her Car Starts Beeping

The 10 Cheapest Hybrids You Can Buy in 2025

The Kia Sportage PHEV Gets a Tiny Price Increase for 2026

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motor1.com?

Take our 3 minute survey.

- The Motor1.com Team

Share this Story