Home
News
Trending
Mechanic Gets Hired to Replace 'Brake Pads Only.' Then He Looks at the Rotor Assembly and Can’t Believe His Eyes
“Pads only?!”

Photo by: Kenny Eliason & Benjamin Brunner
Nina Hernandez 
By: Nina Hernandez
Sep 28, 2025 at 4:00pm ET
Add Motor1.com as a preferred source in Google
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.motor1.com%2Fnews%2F773937%2Fmechanic-customer-brake-pads-only%2F&text=Mechanic%20Gets%20Hired%20to%20Replace%20%27Brake%20Pads%20Only.%27%20Then%20He%20Looks%20at%20the%20Rotor%20Assembly%20and%20Can%E2%80%99t%20Believe%20His%20Eyes&via=motor1com)
- copy
Share
Comment
A mechanic begins what he thinks will be a simple brake pad change and discovers the car desperately needs new rotors.
Diary of a Mechanic (@mechanicaldiary) posts videos of his work exploits on TikTok. In a Sep. 5 video, he reveals that a customer came in and ordered him to change the brake pads—and nothing else.
The mechanic didn’t realize how big of an issue that would be until he started the job and found extremely worn and cracked rotors. You can only guess how many times this customer has ordered the “pads only” special. “Customer states: Replace pads only,” the mechanic writes in the onscreen text.
In the caption, he reiterates, “Pads only?!”
Viewers React to the ‘Pads Only’ Customer’s Rotor Assembly
In the comments, viewers expressed concern about the safety of whoever chooses to drive this vehicle with worn out rotors.
“I’m sorry, but how? Does the owner of this vehicle have to remind themselves to breathe as well?” asked one.
“Is that a rotor or an oversized heavy throwing blade?” joked a second person.
![]()
“Like pads are the least of your worries,” said a third viewer.
Someone else said, “Had to have been making noises and not braking properly for some time.”
Another person joked, “That’s the new racing version with weight reduction.” The mechanic replied, “Anti-heat rotor.”
Is It Safe to Drive With Rotors Like This?
Brake rotors work together with the brake pads to slow your car down when you hit the brake pedal. Due to the friction, both components will wear out over time. So this customer’s strategy of replacing just the pads is not going to work indefinitely.
Driving with bad rotors puts your car at risk of brake failure, which can lead to an accident. It can also impact your ability to handle the vehicle, which is also a safety risk. It makes sense to check in with your mechanic and ask about the state of your rotors before insisting on a pads only replacement.
A Reddit user posted to r/cars five years ago asking if this is a good idea. One person responded, “Inspect [the rotors] for extreme wear, and if you’re in doubt ask a professional to inspect them.”
What do you think?
View
Comments
Another person said, “Depends on the rotors. If they are chewed up at all they will wear your pads down quickly. If they are smooth, you can get away without changing them.”
Motor1 contacted Diary of a Mechanic via TikTok comment and direct message for comment. We’ll update this if he responds.
More From Motor1
'It’s True:' Mechanic Says This Is the ‘Real Reason’ Gen Z Doesn’t Want to Work In His Industry
'Don’t Look At Me:' Mechanic Leaves Work. Then the Car Next to Him Starts Overheating
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motor1.com?
Take our 3 minute survey.
- The Motor1.com Team
Share this Story
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.motor1.com%2Fnews%2F773937%2Fmechanic-customer-brake-pads-only%2F&text=Mechanic%20Gets%20Hired%20to%20Replace%20%27Brake%20Pads%20Only.%27%20Then%20He%20Looks%20at%20the%20Rotor%20Assembly%20and%20Can%E2%80%99t%20Believe%20His%20Eyes&via=motor1com)
- copy
GO TO COMMENTS
(
)
Got a tip for us? Email: tips@motor1.com
View all comments ( )
Popular

I Bought This Skoda 10 Years Ago. I Don't Think I'll Ever Sell It

BYD's Boxy SUV Banned In The EU After Land Rover Defender Copycat Ruling

What If Koenigsegg Had A Sterrato Fighter? Meet The Jesko Terrang

Audi Has 7 New Models Coming In 2027. Here's All Of Them
Latest Stories
- Why Do Some Countries Drive On The Left Side Of The Road? Nov 21 - Motor101 -
- I Bought This Skoda 10 Years Ago. I Don't Think I'll Ever Sell It Nov 21 - Opinion -
- This Chevy Engine's Timing Belt Should Last 150,000 Miles. A Teardown Says Otherwise Nov 21 - Engines -
- Most Drivers Have No Idea What The Little Switch Under Their Rearview Mirror Does Nov 21 - Motor101 -
- BYD's Boxy SUV Banned In The EU After Land Rover Defender Copycat Ruling Nov 21 - Corporate / Financial -
- Ram CEO: New Dakota Will Do 'Some Serious Fun Things' Nov 20 - Manufacturing / Production -
- Can You Drive An American Car In Europe? Yes, But It's Complicated Nov 20 - Motor101 -
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

BYD's Boxy SUV Banned In The EU After Land Rover Defender Copycat Ruling

Ram CEO: New Dakota Will Do 'Some Serious Fun Things'

Can You Drive An American Car In Europe? Yes, But It's Complicated

Hyundai Sonata Dead In Australia, But America Still Wants Sedans

Waymo Just Paused Driverless Freeway Rides Across The US (Update)

Hyundai's Supercar Dream Is (Probably) Dead

Koenigsegg Is Now Worth $1.4 Billion After New Investment