'2K Is Insane:' Woman Gets New York State Inspection Done at Mechanic. Then She Sees What Else They Tacked onto Her Bill

"Avoid the stealerships."

Los Angeles Woman Gets New York State Inspection Done at Mechanic. Then She Sees What Else They Tacked onto Her Bill

Photo by: livin_laughin_lovin_

Alexandra Samuels

By: Alexandra Samuels

Sep 21, 2025 at 1:00pm ET

Add Motor1.com as a preferred source in Google

Comment

A woman claims she was “scammed” into paying for more car services than she asked for during what was supposed to be a quick visit to the mechanic.

TikTok creator @livin_laughin_lovin_ filmed herself at a dealership, explaining that she only came in for an oil change and a New York state inspection. But while she waited, she decided to turn it into a game: “Let’s see what else they try and tack on.”

In other words, she wanted to see what additional services the mechanics would recommend—and how much they’d try to upsell her. “Am I getting scammed at the car service department?” she asks in the text overlay of her clip.

Stay informed with our newsletter every weekday

back

Subscribe For more info, read our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use.

While it’s not clear whether she was actually scammed, the mechanics did suggest extra services—something she implied happens often to women who go to mechanics alone. “Just girly things,” she says.

In another text overlay, she claims, “THEY TRIED TO CHARGE ME 2K TO CHANGE THE BREAKS.”

Why Women Get ‘Scammed’ at the Mechanic

Studies show women are often quoted higher prices at auto shops or told they need extra work done, especially when they seem unsure about what a repair should cost or whether the service is really necessary.

This type of scammy behavior doesn’t happen everywhere—many mechanics are honest—but the pattern is well-documented.

'You Sell To Carvana, You Do Not Buy From Them:' Woman Gets GM Car From Carvana. Then It Almost Kills Them 1 Hour In

A 2017 Harvard Business School study found that women who called a repair shop and admitted they didn’t know the going rate were quoted about $20 more than men who said the same thing. Researchers believe some mechanics assume men will spot an inflated price, while women are more likely to accept it. When customers, regardless of gender, said they knew the average price, the gap disappeared.

The problem goes beyond higher quotes. Some women say they’ve been pushed into unnecessary services or told parts were replaced when they weren’t. Dishonest shops can exploit a customer’s discomfort in a male-dominated space, betting they’ll be too intimidated to challenge the bill.

There are plenty of ways to protect yourself. Look up prices before you head in, call a few different shops to compare, and try to get estimates in writing. Don’t be afraid to ask the mechanic to point out the problem and give you the old parts back if they’re replacing something. For big repairs, getting a second opinion can save you money and stress. And if you want a shop where you feel completely comfortable, female-owned businesses like Girls Auto Clinic focus on making the whole process straightforward and empowering for women.

Viewers Agree: Get a Second Opinion

In the caption of her video, @livin_laughin_lovin_ asks viewers to “help a girly pop out,” which likely means she was looking for advice on whether she was being scammed. While it’s impossible to know without seeing the state of @livin_laughin_lovin_’s car—or her brakes—many commenters urged her to get a second opinion and take time to find a trusted mechanic.

“$2k is crazy, but look into getting your brakes changed somewhere else,” one person recommended.

“It’s always good to have a trusted mechanic,” another added.

“$2k for brakes is insane,” said a third. “Avoid the stealerships whenever possible.”

What do you think?

View

Comments

@livin_laughin_lovin_ responded to that comment: “Yes, I said no, thank you! They think I have coins or something!”

Motor1 has reached out to @livin_laughin_lovin_ via a TikTok direct message. We’ll update this if she responds.