Home
News
Technology
Big Surprise: Study Says Humans Drive Better in Twilight Than Automated Tech
The study also found human drivers are better at navigating intersections.

Christopher Smith 
By: Christopher Smith
Jun 24, 2024 at 1:03pm ET
Add Motor1.com as a preferred source in Google
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.motor1.com%2Fnews%2F724353%2Fstudy-human-drivers-automated-assist%2F&text=Big%20Surprise%3A%20Study%20Says%20Humans%20Drive%20Better%20in%20Twilight%20Than%20Automated%20Tech&via=motor1com)
- copy
Share
Comment
Driver-assist systems with partial automation can certainly help prevent collisions, but they aren't quite ready for primetime. A recent study analyzed over 37,000 vehicle collisions and found humans are less likely to crash on turns or in low-light situations versus automated tech. And the numbers aren't even close.
The study, published recently by Nature Communications, found that vehicles using automated systems had five times as many crashes during sunrise or sunset. In corners, the ratio was twice as many compared to human-driven vehicles. Approximately 35,000 crashes involving human drivers and 2,100 with automated systems active serve as the foundation for the data.
With regard to low-light situations, the study highlights limitations with cameras and sensors and the inability to adapt to conditions. For example, early-morning or late-day shadows could be misinterpreted as objects. Fluctuating light can also be problematic, wreaking havoc with algorithms and causing confusion within the system. On the other hand, objects in shadows may not be detected at all. This is supported by crash tests that consistently show vehicles braking late or failing to stop at all for simulated pedestrians or animals.

As for turns, situational awareness is mentioned as a likely trouble spot for current automated systems. Sensors and cameras may not detect all obstacles in a location as dynamic as an intersection, but it goes beyond even that. The study points out that current systems generally "see" the area relatively close to a vehicle. Whereas a human might see a heavy fog bank a half-mile away and take precautionary action, a car under autonomous control would just keep on going.
What do you think?
View
Comments
There's evidence to back this up. Examining actions taken before a collision, most vehicles under autonomous control were driving straight and at constant speed before emergency maneuvers were implemented. Cars driven by humans showed more cases of slowing down and changing lanes before impact.
The study takes into account a plethora of variables to arrive at these conclusions, but the takeaway is clear. Driver-assist systems as they stand now are just that—assists. Automation works well in a straight line, but considerably more data must be gathered and studied before true hands-off/eyes-off Level 4 driving can become a reality.
Going Hands-Free:
British Columbia Bans All Cars Equipped With Level 3 Driving Assists
Mercedes First To Receive Level 3 ADAS Approval For Use In California
Get the best news, reviews, columns, and more delivered straight to your inbox, daily.
Â
back
Subscribe For more info, read our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use.
Source: Nature via IEEE Spectrum
We want your opinion!
What would you like to see on Motor1.com?
Take our 3 minute survey.
- The Motor1.com Team
Share this Story
- (https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.motor1.com%2Fnews%2F724353%2Fstudy-human-drivers-automated-assist%2F&text=Big%20Surprise%3A%20Study%20Says%20Humans%20Drive%20Better%20in%20Twilight%20Than%20Automated%20Tech&via=motor1com)
- copy
GO TO COMMENTS
(
)
Got a tip for us? Email: tips@motor1.com
View all comments ( )
Popular

12 Cars That Should Easily Make It To 250,000 Miles

Cadillac XT6 Is Returning, And It Won't Be An EV. Here's Everything We Know

Nissan Reveals One Key Design Detail About The Next GT-R

Toyota's New Small Truck Is A Corolla Cross With A Bed

Toyota's Tiny Pickup Could Come To America As A $25,000 Import
Latest Stories
- Running Out Of Gas Once Probably Won't Hurt Your Car. Making It A Habit Might Nov 18 - Motor101 -
- Mercedes Admits It Went Too Far With Screens. But Digital Controls 'Still Feel Right' Nov 18 - Technology -
- America's Speed Limits Make No Sense Nov 18 - Motor101 -
- Toyota's Tiny Pickup Could Come To America As A $25,000 Import Nov 18 - Official -
- Cadillac XT6 Is Returning, And It Won't Be An EV. Here's Everything We Know Nov 18 - Everything We Know -
- Toyota's New Small Truck Is A Corolla Cross With A Bed Nov 18 - Official -
- What Actually Happens When You Press Your Car's Brake Pedal? Nov 18 - Motor101 -
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Nissan Turns Discarded Pineapple Leaves Into High-Performance Car Parts

Toyota's New Small Truck Is A Corolla Cross With A Bed

Audi A2 E-Tron Can Power Your Home And Charge Your Devices

What Actually Happens When You Press Your Car's Brake Pedal?

Disney Is Testing 'Cars' Robots To Help You Find A Parking Spot

12 Cars That Should Easily Make It To 250,000 Miles

The Manual C8 Corvette Is Real, And Really Expensive